Free shipping over $30 90-day returns Lifetime satisfaction guarantee

Compatible HP 58A Black Toner Cartridge (3,000 pages)

Replaces HP 58A (CF258A) · SKU TS-HP58A

$21.38 Genuine $146.99 Save $125.61, 85%

3,000 pages, about 0.7¢ per page

Buying for the office? The price drops with quantity.

  • 2 or more$20.88 eachsave 2%
  • 4 or more$18.23 eachsave 15%

Applied automatically in the cart. The break is per cartridge.

Orders of $300 or more get $10 off at checkout.

  • Free shipping over $30
  • Lifetime satisfaction guarantee
  • 90-day returns, including opened cartridges that are defective
  • Printer damage protection on every cartridge we sell

Buying for an office? See business pricing

This compatible 58A prints about 3,000 pages at roughly 0.7¢ a page and replaces the genuine HP 58A. It fits the HP LaserJet Enterprise M406dn, HP LaserJet Enterprise M406n and HP LaserJet Enterprise MFP M430f and 10 other HP models. It ships with a new chip, so the printer reads the toner level.

Will this fit my printer?

HP builds these printers with dynamic security. HP says they are designed to work only with cartridges that have a new or reused HP chip, and firmware updates keep that in place. Remanufactured cartridges that reuse the original HP chip keep working. Check our fit list before ordering.

Fits 13 printer models. Pick yours to see everything else it takes.

Find your cartridge

or pick your printer

Specifications

Replaces OEM numberHP 58A
Also written asCF258A, HP58A, HP 58A
ColorBlack
Rated yield3,000 pages (ISO/IEC 19752 (HP: "Approximate average yield based on ISO/IEC 19752"))
Yield classStandard yield
Cost per page0.7¢ at our price
ChipIncluded, reports toner level
BuildConfirmed with the supplier before launch
Facts checked2026-09-17 by Dan Whitaker, Print Technician

Specs from hp.com, hp.com, bhphotovideo.com, staples.com.

Genuine 58A vs ours

Genuine HP 58ATonerInkWorld 58A
Price$146.99$21.38
Rated yield3,000 pages3,000 pages
Cost per page4.9¢0.7¢
Printer warrantyUnaffectedUnaffected under the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act
ReturnsVaries by seller90 days, opened defective cartridges included

Genuine price from B&H OEM listing; hp.com PDP would not render a price. Earlier LD Products OEM page check on 2026-09-17 showed $125.48., checked Sep 17, 2026. Source. Prices move, so we re-check monthly.

How to install it

  1. Open the cartridge door on the front of the printer.
  2. Pull the old cartridge straight out.
  3. Take the new cartridge out of its bag and rock it gently five or six times end to end.
  4. Pull the sealing tab straight out to remove the tape.
  5. Line the cartridge up with the guides inside the printer and push it in until it seats.
  6. Close the door and print a test page.

If something goes wrong

The printer does not recognize the cartridge

Power the printer down, reseat the cartridge, check the chip for damage, and confirm the cartridge matches your exact model. If the message stays, check whether a firmware update changed how the printer reads third-party chips.

Full guide

Pages come out blank or very light

Nine times out of ten the sealing tape is still in place or the cartridge needs rocking to spread the toner. Pull the cartridge, check the tape, rock it gently, and reinstall.

Full guide

Streaks or a repeating mark down the page

Streaks usually come from the drum, not the toner. Clean the corona wire if your printer has one, and check the drum count before replacing the cartridge again.

Full guide

Questions about the 58A

How many pages does a 58A print?

About 3,000 pages. The rating follows ISO/IEC 19752 (HP: "Approximate average yield based on ISO/IEC 19752"). That is a rated average, so heavy graphics use toner faster than plain text.

58A or 58X: which one fits my printer?

Both fit the same printers. The 58A is the standard-yield cartridge and the 58X is the high-yield one, so the difference is how often you swap it, not whether it works.

Does a compatible cartridge void my printer warranty?

No. Under the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act a manufacturer cannot void your warranty just because you used a third-party cartridge. If a cartridge of ours damages your printer, our printer damage protection covers the repair.

What if it does not work in my printer?

Send it back. Returns are open for 90 days and that includes opened cartridges that are defective. Shipping is free both ways.

14 reviews for Compatible HP 58A Black Toner Cartridge

  1. David W. Austin, TX

    Reliable so far

    The printer gets used throughout the week at the supply room desk. This went into the printer at the supply room desk. Print has stayed dark and even and output has been consistent. It has been dependable.

  2. Karen K. Austin, TX

    Happy with it

    This went into the printer at the property office. Output has been consistent and installation was straightforward. That is all I need from it.

  3. Tyler D. Indianapolis, IN

    Reliable so far

    I bought it for restaurant use. Pages are coming out clean. It has been dependable.

  4. Nick R. Dallas, TX

    No issues

    This went into the printer at the project office. Output has been consistent and it has handled our normal volume without trouble. It did the job.

  5. Chris P. Denver, CO

    Reliable so far

    I handle the supply ordering for our business office. We mainly print insurance forms, and the printer recognized it right away. No complaints so far.

  6. Michael Z. Pittsburgh, PA

    Would reorder

    For us, consistency matters more than anything fancy. I bought it for construction office use. It has handled our normal volume without trouble. That is all I need from it.

  7. Jessica J. Raleigh, NC

    Does the job

    We mainly print packing slips, and we have not seen streaking. It has been dependable.

  8. Emily B. Indianapolis, IN

    Happy with it

    We keep a spare nearby because inspection sheets cannot really wait. I bought it for auto shop use. Pages are coming out clean. Good fit for what we print.

  9. Rachel B. Raleigh, NC

    Clean prints

    I bought it for veterinary clinic use. Pages are coming out clean. I would order it again.

  10. Jeff F. Chicago, IL

    Reliable so far

    We keep a spare nearby because workpapers cannot really wait. This went into the printer at our accounting office. Print has stayed dark and even and small text is sharp. Happy with the results.

  11. Monica G. Boise, ID

    Good fit

    The printer gets used throughout the week at our service counter. This went into the printer at our service counter. We have not had any cartridge errors and the first pages looked good and it has stayed that way. Good fit for what we print.

  12. Amanda V. Cleveland, OH

    Reliable so far

    I handle the supply ordering for my rental office. I bought it for Airbnb host use. We have not had any cartridge errors. Good fit for what we print.

  13. Nicole L. Grand Rapids, MI

    No issues

    Most of our printing is reports. Pages are coming out clean and we have not seen streaking. I would buy another.

  14. Brandon Z. Cleveland, OH

    Works well

    We do not have time to fuss with supplies when we are printing night audit reports. I bought it for hotel use. It has handled our normal volume without trouble. It has been dependable.

Only logged in customers who have purchased this product may leave a review.

Pairs with