
58A
Compatible HP 58A Black Toner Cartridge
3,000 pages
Your LaserJet PRO MFP M428dw takes the 58A (standard yield) and 58X (high yield). The drum is built into the cartridge, so there is no separate drum to buy. At our price that is about 0.3¢ a page.
The HP LaserJet PRO MFP M428dw is a mono laser printer in the LaserJet Pro MFP M428 series, which shares cartridges across 4 models.
It takes two black cartridges that differ only in capacity: the 58A at about 3,000 pages and the 58X at about 10,000. At our prices that is 0.7¢ a page against 0.3¢, so the high-yield cartridge costs less to run unless you print very little.
On this printer the drum is built into the cartridge, so there is no separate drum to buy or reset. Every new cartridge brings a fresh drum with it.
When you compare prices, compare cost per page rather than the sticker price: a cheaper cartridge with half the rated yield costs more to run. Orders over $30 ship free, and every cartridge is covered by our printer damage protection and can be returned within 90 days, opened or not.

58A
3,000 pages

58X
10,000 pages
| Cartridge | Yield | Price | Per page |
|---|---|---|---|
| 58A | 3,000 pages | $21.38 | 0.7¢ |
| 58X High yield | 10,000 pages | $31.70 | 0.3¢ |
About $9.66 a month in toner, roughly one 58X every 3 months.
The 58A and 58X. HP lists these cartridges as compatible with this model, and the yields on this page are HP's published figures.
No. The drum is built into the toner cartridge, so every new cartridge brings a fresh drum with it. There is no separate drum to buy or reset.
No. Under the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act a manufacturer cannot void your warranty because you used a third-party cartridge. If one of ours damages the printer, our printer damage protection covers the repair.
Most of these share the same cartridges. Check the model page to be sure.
or pick your printer
Page updated Sep 22, 2026. Compatibility checked by Dan Whitaker, Print Technician. Brand names and part numbers are used only to identify compatibility. We are not affiliated with or endorsed by any printer manufacturer.