Free shipping over $30 90-day returns Lifetime satisfaction guarantee

Why is my printer not recognizing the toner cartridge?

A “cartridge not recognized” or “toner error” message usually means the cartridge is not seated correctly, the chip is damaged or not reading, or the printer is checking for its own brand’s chip. Reseat the cartridge first, then check the chip and model match, then check whether a firmware update changed how the printer reads third-party chips.

What the message usually means

Each brand words it differently. Here is what the manufacturers say their own messages mean.

  • Brother “Cartridge Error”: Brother says this appears “if the toner cartridge is not installed correctly” (Brother support).
  • Brother “Toner Error” (color models): one or more toner cartridges are not installed, or not installed correctly (Brother support).
  • Canon “Cart. communication error”: Canon lists two causes. The cartridge may not be installed correctly or may be faulty, or it may not be a genuine Canon product (Canon imageCLASS manual).
  • Lexmark “Replace unsupported cartridge [32.xy]”: Lexmark says codes such as 32.13 and 32.16 indicate a non-genuine Lexmark cartridge. It also says the error can come from a genuine Lexmark cartridge that is not intended for that printer, such as the wrong high-yield cartridge (Lexmark support).
  • HP “unauthorized” cartridge: on printers where an administrator has turned on HP’s Cartridge Policy, the control panel displays a message that the cartridge is unauthorized (HP LaserJet Pro M404 user guide).

Step 1: Reseat the cartridge

Brother and Canon both list this step first.

  1. Remove all packing material. HP’s guide says to check that the sealing tape has been removed.
  2. On Brother printers, take out the toner cartridge and drum unit assembly, separate the toner cartridge from the drum, put it back into the drum unit, and reinstall the assembly. If the error continues, Brother says to contact Brother Customer Service.
  3. On Canon printers, re-install the toner cartridge. Canon says that if re-installing does not clear the message, the cartridge may be faulty and you should contact the store where you bought it.

Step 2: Check the chip and the model match

  • Look at the chip. HP’s troubleshooting steps include checking the cartridge’s memory chip for damage.
  • Confirm the cartridge fits your exact printer. Lexmark’s note about genuine cartridges triggering the error in the wrong model applies to any cartridge.
  • Use a new cartridge, not a swapped one. For toner messages that stay on after a replacement, Brother says to install a brand new, unused cartridge. It says moving cartridges between machines or installing a partially used one may cause the issue (Brother support).
  • On Brother, check you replaced the right part. Brother lists replacing the drum instead of the toner, and a dirty corona wire, as causes of persistent toner messages. Our Brother toner reset guide covers this in more detail.

Step 3: On HP, check Cartridge Policy and dynamic security

HP has two separate features that can block a non-HP cartridge.

Cartridge Policy is a setting. HP says it allows only genuine HP cartridges and is off by default. On the M404 and M405, an administrator can turn it off at Setup > Supply Settings > Cartridge Policy > Off. If your office IT team manages the printer, ask them first.

Dynamic security is not a setting you can change. HP’s M404 guide says: “Cartridges using a non-HP chip or modified or non-HP circuitry might not work. And, those that work today might not work in the future.” HP suggests asking your supplier whether a non-HP cartridge has an original HP security chip or unmodified HP circuitry. HP’s dynamic security document says cartridges that reuse an original HP security chip “are unaffected by dynamic security,” and that changes “can occur through firmware updates delivered over the Internet” (HP dynamic security document). See our HP dynamic security guide for more.

Firmware cuts both ways

Brother lists outdated firmware as one cause of toner messages that will not clear, and says to update it if a newer version exists. HP’s own documents say dynamic security changes can arrive through firmware updates. So an update can fix a message on one printer and start one on another.

If you run third-party cartridges in an HP printer, check with your cartridge supplier before installing a firmware update. HP’s M404 guide shows how updates are run: from the control panel at Setup > Printer Maintenance > Update Firmware, or with the HP Printer Update utility.

Does a compatible cartridge void the printer warranty?

Canon’s on-screen text for this error says “Use of non-Canon cartridges is not covered by the warranty.” The FTC says: “Federal law says a manufacturer can’t require you to use specific parts or services to keep the warranty coverage unless it gives you the parts and services for free or gets a waiver from the FTC” (FTC). Brother’s wording is more specific: its limited warranty “does not apply to any problem or damage caused by the use of third party drum units, toner cartridges, or toner” (Brother support). That wording is about problems or damage the third-party supply causes.

The honest part

You will find tips online to put tape over the chip or rub the contacts with alcohol. None of the manufacturer pages we checked describe either one. The steps they do publish are simpler: reseat the cartridge, check the chip for damage, confirm the model, and update firmware where the manufacturer suggests it.

Third-party cartridges also have real limits. Canon’s message for this error also says the amount remaining in the cartridge “cannot be displayed correctly.” HP states plainly that cartridges with non-HP chips that work today might not work in the future. No compatible seller, including us, can promise otherwise on an HP printer with dynamic security.

If you have reseated the cartridge, checked the chip and model, and the printer still rejects one of our cartridges, see our guarantee and returns page.

Common questions

What does Cartridge Error mean on a Brother printer?

Brother says the message appears if the toner cartridge is not installed correctly. Take the toner cartridge out of the drum unit, put it back in, and reinstall the assembly.

Why does my HP printer reject a non-HP cartridge?

Either an administrator has turned on HP's Cartridge Policy, which allows only genuine HP cartridges, or the printer uses HP dynamic security. HP says cartridges with non-HP chips might not work, and those that work today might not work in the future.

Can a firmware update stop a compatible cartridge from working?

On HP printers, yes. HP says dynamic security changes can arrive through firmware updates delivered over the Internet, so check with your cartridge supplier before updating.

Does using a compatible cartridge void my printer warranty?

The FTC says a manufacturer can't require specific parts to keep warranty coverage unless it provides them free or gets an FTC waiver. Brother's warranty excludes problems or damage caused by third-party drums, toner cartridges or toner.

Why does my printer show the wrong toner level with a compatible cartridge?

Some printers cannot read levels from third-party chips. Canon's error message, for example, says the amount remaining in the cartridge cannot be displayed correctly.

Sources

We link every page we took a fact from. Our editorial standards explain how this content is researched and updated.